Steve Diasparra

Randy Bucks

Elissa Dowling

Woman in Flashback

Mark Polonia

Station Manager

Jeff Kirkendall

Interviewee - Killers Neighbor

Kyle Rappaport

Terry (archive footage)

Maria Davis

Interviewee - Angry Woman

Jamie Morgan

Sam

Mariah Joyce

Jane

Nicholas Olsen

A.J.

Christopher Beacom

Thug

James Carolus

Camp Blood Killer

Greta Volkova

Ginny (archive footage)

Melissa Heflin

Anne (archive footage)

Wyatt Wood

Drake (archive footage)

Titus Himmelberger

Bishop (archive footage)

Tim Hatch

Interviewee - Concerned Citizen

Tina Krause

Nancy (archive footage)