Emmy Perry

Siren Phillips

Morgan Fairchild

Principal Strauss

Elisabeth Röhm

Tiffany

Jack Dylan Grazer

Adam Wilts

Nikki Hahn

Crystal

Stephen Snedden

Gary Wilts

Sterling Sulieman

Brodie

Mason Cotton

Martin

Noree Victoria

Amber

Elsie Fisher

Hayden

Hannah Fraser

Emerald

Lily Berlina

Mrs. Harper

Judy Tenuta

Shopkeeper

Emily Rued

Betty

Kimberly Daugherty

Quinn

A Leslie Kies

Nurse Helen

Jeff Odachowski

Terrin

Elvira Sinelnik

Mermaid (as Elvira Safiulina)

Grant Dugger

Hunter

Gabriel Gabbard

Hunter

P.J. Jenkins

Hunter

Franko Marcano

Hunter