Natalia Livingston

Jackie Fletcher

Brooke Butler

Isabel Fletcher

David Chokachi

Matt Fletcher

Fede Rangel

Nanny

Krystal Torres

Tenant

Matthew Ziff

Jeremy

Christopher Showerman

Agent Willis

Britain Simons

Ben

Ciara Flynn

Allison

Heidi Fielek

Elise

Wolfgang Bodison

Detective Phillips

Chris Bound

Officer

Taylor Cole

Skater Boy

David Donah

FBI Agent

Jaime Gallagher

Julianna Hargrove

Jackson Garner

Tommy Fletcher

Michael London

FBI Agent Michael

Meredyth Lynn

Search Party Member

Natalie MacInnis

Runner

Melanie Monroe

Margaret

Federica Rangel

Nanny

Margeaux Reign

Child at Storytime

Meadow Rico

Child at Storytime

Angie Russo

Allison (voice)

Kasey Shirk

Party Girl

Olivia Sky

Gabby's Nanny (as Olivia Dudek)

Taylor Stanley

Radzicki

Elijah Lee Williams

Skater