In a spoof of Siskel and Ebert's Sneak Previews, Telly and Oscar are seen in a movie theater, reviewing the silliest songs from Sesame Street. Telly loves all of them and he gives them 5 "Wows". Oscar, however, dislikes them and gives them 5 "Phooeys" (but ends up liking the last clip).
Martin P. Robinson
Telly Monster / Monty (voice)
Caroll Spinney
Oscar the Grouch (voice)
Judy Sladky
Alice Snuffleupagus (voice) (archive footage)
Annette Calud
Celina (archive footage)
Lexine Bondoc
Lexine (archive footage)
Bob McGrath
Bob Johnson (archive footage)
David Rudman
Humphrey (voice) (archive footage)
Joey Mazzarino
Ingrid (voice) (archive footage)
Kevin Clash
Natasha (voice) (archive footage)
