David Howard Thornton

Steamboat Willie

Jesse Kove

Lieutenant Diaz

Jesse Posey

Pete

Charles Edwin Powell

Borough President Molinari

Amy Schumacher

Amber

Jarlath Conroy

Barry

Allison Pittel

Selena

Jarod Lindsey

Moses

Rumi C. Jean-Louis

Matteo

Anthony E. Williams

Officer Martinez

Tyler Posey

Radio Operator Mike

Jared Johnston

Neil

Brian Quinn

Mitch McEverly

Kailey Hyman

Cindi

Brian Scolaro

Captain Clark

Sarah Kopkin

Ilsa Arindel

Tommy Bechtold

TJ

Joe DeRosa

Paul Sanguino

Ken Maharaj

Albert (as Kenneth Maharaj)

Savannah Whitten

Ariana

Michael Leavy

Deckhand Bert Brunswick

Stephanie Bates

Bella

Poonam Basu

Jazzy

Jayme Woj

Deckhand Roscoe

Steven Della Salla

Charlie DeLorenzo

Jason Lockhart

Cyclist Peter

Allyson Sereboff

Aubrey

Julia Schroeder

Dominique

Rachel Victoria Moore

Jamie

Corey Militzok

Phillip

Michael Defilippis

First Mate Tommy

Gilbrando Acevedo

The Shirtless Cowboy

Allie Seibold

Rory

Alexandra Acosta

Hilda

Buzz Roddy

Officer Pat O'Hare

Peter Romano

Officer Chris

Tammi Cubilette

Liz

Cassandra Ruiz

Frankie