Karl Glusman

Elliot

Alicia Silverstone

Sophie

Catherine Curtin

Peggy

Sergi Martos

French Waiter

Britne Oldford

Sam

Monica Rae Summers Gonzalez

Off-Broadway Bartender

Kyle Bary

Dan

Paul McCallion

Morgan (Sophie's Assistant)

John Wollman

David

Esteban Benito

Paul

Mike Rob

Jordan

Tammy Blanchard

Amanda (Sophie's Sister)

Sorika Horng

Jane

Nicole Annunziata

Amy

Austin Colby

Tech Bro

Michael Gwinnett

Cabaret Maître D (uncredited)