Kim Matula

Katherine

Ian Harding

Peter

Beth Leavel

Susan Kraine

Lori Tan Chinn

Arlene

Reginald VelJohnson

Roy

Kathleen Garrett

Mrs. Winchester

Christopher Innvar

Robert Baron

Kate MacCluggage

Lily Baron

Julian Gamble

Grampa Bob

Blair Baker

Charlie

Liana Hunt

Betsey

Jack Carter Barton

Teen Peter

Leo James Davis

Middle Peter

Christopher Riley

Young Peter

Stanton Nash

Bob

Meghan O'Leary-Clark

Rachel

Kendyl Ito

Neighbor

JB Chen

Robert business associate

Juan Carlos Infante

Gabe

Anna Clare Kerr

Peter's mother (1956)

Austin Schoenfeld

Devon

Steve Antonucci

Valet (uncredited)

Warren Smith II

Carousel Kid (uncredited)

Sara McDermott

Ghost (uncredited)

Estavion White

Reporter (uncredited)